The decade-long battle of ‘Who’s superior?’ between fertilizers vs manure results from multiple factors namely, awareness regarding eco-friendly practices, the need to produce higher yield, unhealthy food, and many others. While both manures and fertilizers hold a large market sector in gardening, they differ significantly in their composition, application methods, and long-term impact on soil and the environment. It’s crucial to understand these differences to make informed decisions for a thriving garden.
This blog dives into the five key differences between fertilizers and manure to help you choose at every stage of your plant’s life.
1. Origin and Composition
There is a significant difference between the origin and composition of manures and fertilizers.
Manure
It is an organic and natural substance derived from the decomposition of various products such as;
-
animal waste (such as cow dung, worm castings, end-products of poultry animals, etc.),
-
domestic waste,
-
plant residues, or green cover crops like clover
-
Sludge
-
Biogas slurry
-
Human waste
The composition of manure is similar to that of fertilizers. It contains essential nutrients such as nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium, and magnesium, required for plant growth and development. However, these nutrients are present in relatively low concentrations compared to fertilizers. Manure is composed of organic matter, which aids in improving the soil structure and supporting microbial activity.
Fertilizers
In general terms, Fertilizer is an inorganic salt that is manufactured with chemical compounds designed to provide plants with specific nutrients in concentrated forms. However, with the advancement of technology, the fertilizer industry has been categorized into two forms;
-
synthetic fertilizers (e.g., urea, ammonium nitrate), are completely manufactured using chemical compounds
-
and organic fertilizers (e.g., bone meal, fish emulsion, oil cakes). The source of raw material to manufacture the organic fertilizers is compost. The composition of fertilizers is nutrient-specific and often labeled with their NPK ratio, indicating the proportion of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium they contain.
Pro Tip: If your goal is to enrich your soil with nutrients naturally and enhance its structure, manures are the go-to product. However, if your plant is devoid of any specific nutrient and needs it in concentrated form, then fertilizers would be an ideal choice.
2. Nutrient Release Rate
Just like the human body requires food and water to function properly, nutrients are the food for plants. The amount and consistency with which they receive their food is extremely crucial for their growth. A gardener must avoid overfeeding as well as under-feeding the plants with nutrients. Hence, the nutrient release rate in Fertilizers vs Manure is another critical difference important to have an informed decision.
Manure
Even though manure is obtained from the decomposition of organic waste, the process of decomposition never truly ceases. Therefore, manure releases nutrients slowly as it decomposes over time. This gradual release ensures a steady supply of nutrients to plants throughout their growth cycle while improving soil health in the long term.
Note: Even though its long-term impact is extremely effective, because of its slow action, manure may not be suitable for addressing immediate nutrient deficiencies.
Fertilizers
The primary reason why the fertilizer industry was established in the agriculture sector was to fulfill the immediate nutrient requirement of the plant. particularly synthetic ones are designed for quick nutrient release. They provide an immediate boost to plants by delivering readily available forms of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. This makes fertilizers an ideal choice when the plant is showing signs of nutrient deficiency.
3. Impact on Soil Health
This key difference between Fertilizers vs Manure holds great significance. Soil is the foundation of the plant and maintaining a healthy structure is crucial for the overall development of a plant throughout its life.
Manure
Manure adds organic matter to the soil. This organic matter does wonders for the soil by not only improving its soil structure but also enhancing water retention, aeration, and drainage capabilities of the soil. Manure also provides the soil with beneficial microorganisms that break down organic matter into beneficial nutrients.
Note: The long-term impact of using manure is healthy and the soil will remain fertile for a longer period. Over time, regular application of manure can also increase resilience against soil erosion.
Fertilizers
Excessive usage of chemical fertilizers degrades soil quality by reducing microbial activity and altering pH levels. Over time, this can lead to compacted soils which is less fertile and hence produces less yield.
Key takeaway: Manure is better for improving overall soil health and structure over time, while fertilizers focus solely on providing nutrients while degrading the physical or biological properties of the soil.
4. Environmental Impact
Earth’s natural environmental implications of using Fertilizers vs Manures cannot be overlooked. It is an important parameter for a sustainable and healthy ecosystem.
Manure
This is one of the primary benefits of using manure that it is eco-friendly when used appropriately. Its impact on the environment is not detrimental but beneficial. Manure’s composition eliminates soil pollution and supports biodiversity within the soil ecosystem.
Precaution: Excessive usage of manure in soil will eventually lead to nutrient burn. Additionally, improper storage causes nutrient runoff into water bodies or methane emissions from decomposing organic matter.
Fertilizers
A major drawback of fertilizers is that they have severe environmental consequences, especially synthetic fertilizers. Overapplication often leads to nutrient leaching into groundwater or runoff into rivers and lakes, causing eutrophication. The production of synthetic fertilizers also leads to greenhouse gas emissions like carbon dioxide (CO2) and nitrous oxide (N2O), which significantly contribute to climate change.
Environmental Tip: To minimize environmental risks while maintaining productivity, consider combining manure with organic fertilizers. You can also adopt sustainable farming practices such as crop rotation or cover cropping.
5. Cost and Accessibility
Budget consideration is the key factor in both gardening and farming. When deciding between Fertilizers vs Manure, cost-effectiveness comes off as a crucial parameter.
Manure
It is often more affordable than commercial fertilizers due to the raw components used. Manure can be sourced locally from farms or through composting organic waste at home. However, due to its lower nutrient composition, larger quantities are required to achieve noticeable results.
Fertilizers
They are more expensive because they undergo complex manufacturing processes that ensure precise formulations of essential nutrients. Despite their higher cost, they are easier to transport and store due to their concentrated nature.
Key takeaway: If budget constraints are a concern or if you have access to local sources of organic waste, manure is a cost-effective option. Fertilizers may be worth the investment when specific nutrient requirements need to be met efficiently.
The Final Verdict: Fertilizers or Manure?
The choice between fertilizers vs manure ultimately depends on your goals:
-
If you prioritize long-term soil health, improved microbial activity, and environmental sustainability, manure is the better option.
-
If you need quick results to address specific nutrient deficiencies or boost crop yield immediately during critical growth stages, fertilizers are more effective.
Pro Tip: For optimal results, many farmers and gardeners use a combination of both; manure for enriching the soil over time and fertilizers for targeted nutrient supplementation during peak growing seasons.
Wrapping It Up
The key differences between manure and fertilizers are the driving forces of tomorrow’s ecosystem. FirstBudAgroSolutions has revolutionized the manure sector by designing scientifically-formulated products that caters to a wide range of issues whether it’s pest infestations or poor water retention in soil. Each FirstBud product empowers your soil to be in nutrient-rich and resistant to diseases leading to thriving gardens!
